I have lived and worked in Southeast Asia for more than 15 years. I have witnessed and participated in several failed data projects. I was also involved in a number of successful data projects, and in this article, I offer a comprehensive roadmap for building financially viable data projects and securing the necessary backing within organizations.
In the digital age, data projects are central to organizational growth and efficiency. However, the path from conception to execution involves careful planning, strategic alignment, and, critically, financial justification. I give a few steps that can be followed to help build a viable data project.
Step 1: Align with Strategic Goals
Understand Organizational Objectives: This is the part that most go wrong. There are so many misconceptions regarding strategy and action plans, and if you do not start with a good strategy, then the whole viable building data product will never be realized. Begin by aligning your data project with the organization’s strategic goals. Whether it’s boosting operational efficiency, enhancing customer experience, or driving innovation, the project should directly contribute to these overarching objectives.
Step 2: Identify and Engage Stakeholders
Stakeholder Engagement: Getting the right people involved is also key. Early and ongoing engagement with stakeholders is crucial. Identify all parties with a vested interest in the project, from executive sponsors to end-users, and involve them in the planning process to ensure their needs and concerns are addressed.
Step 3: Develop a Comprehensive Plan
Project Scope and Roadmap: Define the project’s scope, objectives, and deliverables. Develop a detailed roadmap that outlines each phase of the project, from data collection and analysis to implementation and review.
Step 4: Quantify the Financial Benefits
- Cost-Benefit Analysis: A critical component of justifying a data project is quantifying its potential financial benefits. This involves:
- Cost Savings: Identify areas where the project can reduce operational costs, such as through process automation or improved supply chain efficiency.
- Revenue Growth: Estimate how the project will drive revenue, whether through new product offerings, market expansion, or enhanced customer targeting.
- Efficiency Gains: Calculate time savings and productivity improvements for staff, translating these into financial terms. Use historical data, industry benchmarks, and predictive analytics to support your estimates.
Step 5: Calculate ROI
Return on Investment (ROI): The ROI calculation compares the project’s net benefits (total benefits minus total costs) to its costs. A positive ROI is a strong indicator of a project’s financial viability, making it a persuasive argument for stakeholders. Personally, in Southeast Asia, my practice is also taken into account in terms of the PR value as a part of ROI.
Step 6: Mitigate Risks
Risk Assessment and Mitigation: Identify potential risks to the project, including technical, operational, and financial risks. Develop a mitigation plan for each identified risk, demonstrating proactive management and increasing stakeholder confidence.
Step 7: POC and Scale
Pilot Projects: Where possible, start with a POC project. This is much easier, and you can retain consultancy services to help with the POC. This allows you to demonstrate tangible results with a smaller investment, reduce risks, and refine your approach based on real-world feedback before scaling up.
Step 8: Monitor and Report
- Performance Monitoring: Establish key performance indicators (KPIs) to monitor the project’s success and impact. Regular reporting to stakeholders on these KPIs will not only justify the initial investment but also support future data projects.
- Learning from Failures: A Cautionary NoteFinancial justifications are not foolproof, and data projects can fail for various reasons, including misaligned objectives, underestimated complexities, or overestimated benefits. Learning from these failures is crucial. Analyze what went wrong and why, and use these insights to improve future project planning and justification processes.
Building and justifying data projects financially requires a structured approach that aligns with organizational goals, engages stakeholders, quantifies benefits, and rigorously assesses risks. By meticulously planning and leveraging data to support your financial justifications, you can secure the necessary support and resources to transform data into actionable insights and tangible value for your organization.
In Asia, as in other regions, several ambitious data projects have faced challenges, setbacks, or outright failure. These cases highlight important lessons in project management, data quality, stakeholder engagement, and scalability. Here are a few notable examples:
- India’s Aadhaar Biometric Database Challenges
Overview: Aadhaar, the world’s largest biometric ID system, was launched in India to streamline government services and reduce fraud. While successful in many respects, the project has faced significant challenges related to privacy, data security, and logistical issues in implementation.
What Went Wrong: Despite its achievements, Aadhaar encountered problems, including data breaches, authentication failures, and privacy concerns. In some instances, individuals’ biometric data was compromised or improperly accessed.
Lesson: Large-scale data projects, especially those handling sensitive personal information, require robust data security and privacy measures. Continuous monitoring and updating of security protocols are essential to protect against breaches.
2. South Korea’s Smart City Privacy Concerns
Overview: South Korea has been at the forefront of building smart cities, integrating advanced technologies to create more efficient and livable urban environments. However, some initiatives have faced criticism over surveillance and privacy concerns.
What Went Wrong: The extensive collection of personal data through sensors and cameras raised issues about citizens’ privacy and the potential for government surveillance, leading to public pushback.
Lesson: Transparency and clear communication about data use policies are crucial in gaining public trust for projects involving large-scale data collection, especially in applications that touch on personal privacy.
3. China’s Social Credit System Implementation Challenges
Overview: China’s social credit system aims to rate the trustworthiness of individuals and businesses based on their social and economic behavior. While it’s been implemented in various forms, the system has encountered obstacles, including public concern over privacy, fairness, and transparency.
What Went Wrong: The ambitious project has faced logistical challenges in standardizing criteria across different regions and sectors. Additionally, there have been concerns about the accuracy of data and the ethical implications of using it to restrict individuals’ rights based on their scores.
Lesson: Implementing a universal rating or scoring system for citizens or businesses is fraught with challenges related to data accuracy, ethical considerations, and public acceptance. Such systems need clear, fair, and transparent criteria.
4. Tokyo’s 2020 Olympics App Failures
Overview: For the 2020 Tokyo Olympics, several apps were developed for navigation, information, and services for tourists, athletes, and attendees. However, many of these apps were criticized for being difficult to use, not offering multilingual support, and failing to effectively provide real-time information.
What Went Wrong: The apps faced technical issues, were not user-friendly, and failed to accommodate the diverse needs of an international audience, leading to frustration and limited usage.
Lesson: User experience (UX) is paramount in the development of data-driven applications, especially for international events. Ensuring accessibility, usability, and real-time functionality is critical for success.
These cases from Asia illustrate that while data projects hold immense potential, their implementation is often fraught with challenges that can lead to setbacks or failures. Key takeaways include the importance of safeguarding privacy, ensuring data security, engaging stakeholders, and focusing on user experience. Learning from these experiences can guide future projects toward more successful outcomes.
In Southeast Asia, the digital transformation journey has seen its share of both successes and challenges. Several ambitious data-driven projects have encountered obstacles, offering valuable lessons on the complexities of managing, executing, and scaling such initiatives. Here are a few instances where data projects in the region faced difficulties:
- Philippines’ National Broadband Plan Delays
Overview: Launched with the aim of improving internet access across the Philippines, the National Broadband Plan has faced significant delays and challenges since its announcement. The initiative aimed to leverage government and private sector infrastructure to enhance broadband coverage, especially in underserved areas.
What Went Wrong: Issues included bureaucratic hurdles, funding constraints, and logistical challenges in deploying infrastructure across the country’s many islands. These factors contributed to delays and the slow progress of the project.
Lesson: Large-scale infrastructure projects, particularly those involving new technologies, require clear regulatory frameworks, sufficient funding, and careful logistical planning to address geographical challenges.
2. Thailand’s Rice Data Management System
Overview: Thailand, a major global rice exporter, initiated a project to create a comprehensive data management system for its rice industry, aiming to improve efficiency, traceability, and market intelligence. However, the project encountered several roadblocks.
What Went Wrong: The project struggled with data quality issues, lack of participation from stakeholders across the rice supply chain, and difficulties in integrating diverse data sources. These challenges hindered the system’s effectiveness and adoption.
Lesson: Stakeholder engagement and high-quality data are critical for the success of supply chain management systems. Ensuring the reliability and usability of such systems requires active collaboration across all participants in the ecosystem.
3. Singapore’s Smart Nation Sensor Platform Challenges
Overview: Singapore’s ambitious Smart Nation initiative includes deploying a vast network of sensors and cameras to collect data on everything from traffic to crowd density. While the initiative has seen many successes, it has also faced challenges related to privacy concerns and data security.
What Went Wrong: Public concerns over surveillance and data privacy have led to debates about the balance between technological advancements and individual rights. Ensuring the security of the collected data against cyber threats has also been a challenge.
Lesson: Balancing technological innovation with privacy rights and data security is essential in smart city projects. Public trust is crucial and requires transparent communication about data use and robust security measures.
4. Indonesia’s E-KTP Biometric Identification System Issues
Overview: Indonesia’s electronic ID card (e-KTP) project aimed to provide all citizens with biometric identification cards, consolidating data across government services. Despite its potential, the project was marred by corruption, technical failures, and implementation delays.
What Went Wrong: Corruption scandals involving project funding, technical glitches in biometric data capture and processing, and logistical challenges in a country with vast geographical diversity contributed to its difficulties.
Lesson: Transparency and accountability are paramount in public sector projects, especially those involving large-scale data collection. Additionally, technical and logistical planning must be adapted to local conditions to ensure project success.
These cases from Southeast Asia highlight the importance of addressing logistical, technical, regulatory, and ethical challenges in data projects. For future initiatives to succeed, lessons must be learned in stakeholder engagement, project management, data security, and respecting privacy concerns, ensuring that the immense potential of data-driven projects can be fully realized in the region.
In conclusion, the successful execution and financial justification of data projects require a meticulous, structured approach that aligns with organizational goals, engages stakeholders, quantifies benefits, and assesses risks. By following the steps outlined — aligning with strategic goals, engaging stakeholders, developing a comprehensive plan, quantifying financial benefits, calculating ROI, mitigating risks, piloting, and monitoring — organizations can build a compelling case for their data initiatives.
Learning from past failures is crucial. High-profile data projects across Asia, from India’s Aadhaar to South Korea’s smart cities, demonstrate the challenges of data security, privacy, stakeholder engagement, and scalability. These projects underscore the necessity of robust planning, clear communication, and adaptive management strategies.
The experiences from Southeast Asia further illustrate the complexities of digital transformation, emphasizing the need for high-quality data, strong stakeholder engagement, regulatory clarity, and logistical planning. For instance, the Philippines’ National Broadband Plan and Thailand’s Rice Data Management System highlight the importance of overcoming bureaucratic and data quality hurdles.
Future data projects must balance innovation with ethical considerations, ensuring public trust through transparency and robust data security. By addressing these lessons and adopting a structured approach, organizations can maximize the potential of their data initiatives, transforming data into actionable insights and tangible value.
Alex.Worapol.Pongpech 
Leave a comment